Rentista visa: Still possible to go permanent after 3 years?

[Paige55]

Do you know whether people here on a temporary rentista visa (who have completed three years in the country on a temporary rentista visa) will be able to change to permanent residency at their third renewal? This used to be the case, but a friend is saying her lawyer is now not sure if those under the rentista visa category will ever be able to change to permanent resident status with the new laws in place and may have to continue to simply live here under temporary status under that category. Of course, everything seems to be speculation because the law has just changed but it seems that quickly finding some clarity for those who were on that path would be great so that they don't waste their time thinking it's a viable option to permanent status only to be rejected after expending their time and energy towards a stable future here. Anyone changed their rentista from temp to permanent recently and heard anything about changes to that option recently?

 

[jantango]

Get temporary residence as a renter​

Regulated in article 23 (b) of Law No. 25,871, regulated by Decree No. 616/2010 and Ordinance DNM 1.732/2023 as amended by Ordinance 3446/2023.

Validity​

A temporary residence is granted for a period of 1 year, which can be extended.
------------------------
Unless the law has been changed, you chose a category that only permits an extension.

Instead of annual extensions, consider citizenship with the same documentation.

 

[Paige55]

Get temporary residence as a renter​

Regulated in article 23 (b) of Law No. 25,871, regulated by Decree No. 616/2010 and Ordinance DNM 1.732/2023 as amended by Ordinance 3446/2023.

Validity​

A temporary residence is granted for a period of 1 year, which can be extended.
------------------------
Unless the law has been changed, you chose a category that only permits an extension.

Instead of annual extensions, consider citizenship with the same documentation.

I feel this is up in the air. Many people (some on this forum) have used the rentista visa to acquire permanent residency after three years on its temporary visa path (through the cambio de categoria). While it may never have been 'officially' allowed, it was something that had been possible and even touted by lawyers (who'd had several clients advance to permanent residency after their three years as a temp rentista).

I think with the stricter laws, they'll now be more inclined to mind the original temporary nature of these residency rules (renewable for only three years). Citizenship isn't possible for her, she has to travel back to her home country to visit elderly parents and secure the paperwork for the visa renewals here.

Like permatourists...who've never been encouraged or 'allowed' to overstay or border hop...but their precarious residency was really never dealt with before now...the tightening of rules is just changing the lax nature of the immigration laws and a lot of people will be stuck having to leave. It's a matter of bad timing, a few months earlier...if she'd have been able to change her category on her last renewal, she'd be a permanent resident on the other side of stricter enforcement.

My friend went this route as, upon entering the country, she didn't have upwards of $10,000 fluid dollars to hire an attorney to process a citizenship application without the two years required residency under her belt. So, she did the rentista and now the citizenship rules won't allow for her to seek citizenship without a hefty amount of money to fight the new amendment that requires applicants to not have traveled outside of the country for two years. She's very thankful to have been able to stay, she really saw a future here, but as with immigration all over the world, it's increasingly out of range for many folks that don't have unlimited financial resource. We'll see how things shake out. It might turn out that they still allow that cambio de categoria after all and she's worried for nothing.

 

[jantango]

Citizenship isn't possible for her, she has to travel back to her home country to visit elderly parents and secure the paperwork for the visa renewals here.

Then her status will always be temporary and never permanent.

 

[Paige55]

Citizenship isn't possible for her, she has to travel back to her home country to visit elderly parents and secure the paperwork for the visa renewals here.

Then her status will always be temporary and never permanent.

unfortunately she doesn't have the means to be a rentista forever and I believe those categories are only renewable for three years and then it's not possible to keep on that same path. Hopefully her lawyers will advise her. Who knows. Thank you for the response.

 

[Bajo_cero2]

The DNU 366/2025 downgrade the status of everybody 1 level. Citizens now are permanente residents and PR are temporary and so on. This is why lawyers do not know what to do or advice, even the lawyers who works inside immigration.
The best strategy is to remain in the former law applying at Court but she has to pay fees and now they are more expensive.

 

[foobar]

I can't help with any practical experiences but this website of migraciones clearly states that anyone who has had temporary residency for three years and can prove sufficient financial means and a clean criminal record can apply for permanent residency. Plus we already found out in other threads in this forum that they updated that page with the recent changes of law so it should be up to date.

Radicaciones Residencia Permanente

Regulada por el artículo 22 de la Ley N.º 25.871, modificada por el Decreto N.º 366/2025 y reglamentada por el Decreto N.º 616/2010.

www.argentina.gob.ar

If anyone has any information on why this shouldn't be the case I'd be curious to know.