Being the stubborn Taurean that I am, I went against everyone's advice and decided to check Friday's (Alto Palermo) out. You guys were dead on - it was not exactly the pleasant experience that I had hoped for. The prices were ridiculous, the food was ok and the service was bad.
A recap of my late-lunch: After refusing to pay 18 pesos for a real drink, we had to send our sodas back twice for being completely flat (we finally gave up and ordered water). Then, when the waitress brought the potato skins, one fell on the floor. She said she'd bring another but that never happened. The turkey club I ordered was half the size of what you'd get in the US and was not all that tasty. Then, when they brought us the bill, they tried to charge us for the sodas we had sent back instead of for the water that we were forced to drink. The only thing I can say was that the Potato skins and french fries were really good. Aside from that - blah. I won't be heading back there again.
So thank you all for the advice. I really should have followed it. But I guess sometimes you have to figure things out on your own. Next on my list are Remember El Alamo and Kansas....