It's funny even with the crime I would take Medellin over Buenos Aires. I started learning Spanish here in BA but it was only after I went to Colombia that it finally "clicked". In Buenos Aires it's all the pollo (POSHO) and calle (CASHE) that threw me off. When I got to Colombia I was shocked that I understood when people spoke! Buenos Aires has to be one of the hardest places to begin learning Spanish. Now I understand everything here but it was stressful at the beginning.
In Colombia there is an irresistble musical tone to the accent ( in Medellin and in my opinion). I could listen to it all day.
There is also the attitude of the typical Colombian. They are really a very happy bunch. Forever dancing and laughing. Buenos Aires seems at times to be kind of grumpy. That may be due to the fact that Colombia is growing and expanding and Argentina is well....you know.
It was friends of my friends getting shot. My friends were all university educated and the guy who got shot for his motorcycle was a doctor.
So it's not just the scum. With maybe 1200 homicides a year for Medellin it's hard not to know somebody who knows some of those people. The city is not THAT big.
I'm sorry those people were shot. I didn't mean to imply they were "scum." I simply disagree on how common it is to know people who have been shot and killed, at least now.
And yes, I would also take Medellín over Buenos Aires at this point, if I had to stay in Latin America. It's a damn delight. The city's beautiful, the weather's beautiful, the people are great and finding good, healthy food is not an issue. The paisa accent is my favorite in the country, I think. So fun to listen to. As for Colombia in general, it's such a change to live in a place where the mentality is more, "Hey, we've been through hell, but we're going to have fun and laugh and enjoy life and smile and be happy."
In regards to some other posts, here are some reasons why Colombians continue to move to Argentina:
-Cheaper education (particularly medical school; also, doctors make more in Argentina)
-No more 48-hour work week
-Less work in general. Colombians work like dogs, and often on Saturdays--we all know how Argentines work.
-Less uptight social norms (wear what you want, grow out your hair/beard, dress like a bum, stop wearing makeup, no one cares)
-Relative safety
-The Colombian economy may be doing great if you go by numbers, but most professional salaries are abysmal when you look at the high cost of living, and the job market is extremely competitive.
Why they get sick of Argentina (not so different from everyone else, really):
-Turning into Venezuela and everything that goes along with that--inflation, inability to save in pesos
-Horrible food (the rice, the sugar and salt, the fruits/veggies were the complaints I'd hear most)
-Comparatively rude, unfriendly people; difficulty in making local friends (at least in BA)