Hi! Did you have to pay taxes in Argentina for the cash you transferred? or by just proving taxes paid in the US was enough? Thank you!
If you are asking if you have to pay
income tax in Argentina on the money you transfer from the USA to buy a property here the answer most likely is no, unless you had tax residency in Argentina when you earned the money.
If your US (or worldwaide) income was not subject to taxation in Argentina when you earned it, you will not have to pay taxes in Argentina on that revenue when you transfer it.
The escribanos always ask about the source of the funds, but I am not sure what they will accept as evidence that the funds were legaly acquired. Anyone could get a blank IRS form and fill it out, creating the impression they had declared the funds to the IRS.
I wonder how any escribano would actually know if a signed IRS form was real and had ever been submitted. I had no signed IRS forms or a cancelled check to show I had paid any taxes on the sale of my house in March of 2006, only a copy of the sales agreement and bank statement showing the deposit of the funds into my US bank acount.
It woud have been too soon to actually report the "income" on an IRS tax rerturn and pay any taxes (if owed) on any gain.
When I asked if I would have to pay
any taxes on the transferred funds in Argentina before buying the apartment in late October of 2006. I was told no, as that was money I "earned" before ever living in Argentina with tax residency.
I received my precaria for temporary residency only a few days before I transferred the funds from my US bank to a casa de cambio in Buenos Aires. It was clear I did not have tax residency in Argentina when I "made" the money I transferred.
PS: I arrived in Argentina for the first time in May of 2006, less than two months after the sale of my house.
Hope this helps.