Keeping a US green card while living in Buenos Aires

AlexGreeneBA

Registered
Joined
Oct 31, 2026
Messages
3
Likes
0
Hi everyone — American here, been in BA a little over a year now. I still hold a green card from an old family petition and I'm trying to figure out how much time outside the US is actually safe. Everyone says "six months" but nobody gives the same answer twice.

For those who've kept a green card while living abroad long-term: how much time do you really spend in the US per year, have you ever been questioned at immigration about it, and was the re-entry permit worth the hassle? Curious about real experiences rather than just the official rules. Thanks!
 
Hi everyone — American here, been in BA a little over a year now. I still hold a green card from an old family petition and I'm trying to figure out how much time outside the US is actually safe. Everyone says "six months" but nobody gives the same answer twice.

For those who've kept a green card while living abroad long-term: how much time do you really spend in the US per year, have you ever been questioned at immigration about it, and was the re-entry permit worth the hassle? Curious about real experiences rather than just the official rules. Thanks!
If you're American in a legal, citizen sense, you have a passport -- why would you have a green card and need to keep it active then?
 
Its completly random at this point, but certainly if you dont look "white" you are at risk of being refused entry, green card or no. Its happening all the time.
 
Hi everyone — American here, been in BA a little over a year now. I still hold a green card from an old family petition and I'm trying to figure out how much time outside the US is actually safe. Everyone says "six months" but nobody gives the same answer twice.
There are 35 sovereign countries in the Americas. Which American country are you from?
 
Fair points, all — green card from my mom's petition years ago, not a citizen yet, that's the problem. Thanks for the heads-up, Ries. pixer12, would you push for naturalization first or keep the card and run everything from BA?
 
Howdy Alex,

I think only an attorney could positively tell you what your risk level upon port re-entry is for your specific situation. All you are going to get here is some anecdotal stories which may be completely irrelevant to you.

Just to be clear, you've already been outside the US, living in BA for over a year now and you are not sure when you should go back to retain your greencard?

You are already well past the general 6 month guideline. Why didn't you return earlier?
 
Thanks for the USCIS page, zzingara, the re-entry permit section was the clearest read I've found. LuckyLuke, fair question: I kept telling myself quick trips back would cover it and the flights kept slipping. Booking an attorney consult now, how did people here find a decent one?
 
Booking an attorney consult now, how did people here find a decent one?
Why don't you decide which port of entry you'll use and find a local immigration lawyer there? He'll probably know more about U.S. immigration law than any Argentine lawyer. Plus, if things go wrong, he'll be able to visit you at the detention center.
 
Thanks for the USCIS page, zzingara, the re-entry permit section was the clearest read I've found. LuckyLuke, fair question: I kept telling myself quick trips back would cover it and the flights kept slipping. Booking an attorney consult now, how did people here find a decent one?
Before getting into the details about which attorney and which port. Was exactly is your long term plan? Are you prepared to move to the US until you acquire your citizenship? Are you going to be constantly bouncing back and forth trying to comply with the minimum stay requirements? How would you hold a job under such circumstances?
 
Back
Top