I think you took this wrong, Musicman. I wasn't throwing shade at Brazil, nor was I criticizing your choice. I was just pointing out that, historically, Argentina has been about as stable as a fart in a whirlwind.
My other half and I are considering it for our winter escape. The only thing that puts me off is the safety issue. I’ve been a few times and its definitely a lot rougher round the edges. Any big city in LatAm is compared to BA.
This year we did our winter escape in Leblon and felt very safe. Each building had a 24 hour security guard that was often in front of their building during the day. The beaches were not patrolled but we had no problems. We also made wonderful excursions to Paraty and Ilha Grande with no problems. It was very different from the media reports. We did have one problem, in Corcovado a monkey stole my media luna. I did not report the crime.