Viviana wrote:"Johny, let me shed some light for you. I am trying to help expats
like you to make sound decisions for thier families.I am not
advertising my services. My husband and I help expats get thier DNI's
and residency . I do not know what your legal status is in Argentina
but I suppose you have been fortunate to take advantage of the benefits
of living abroad. You happen to live in a city that is crammed with
over 20 million people, I know I lived in Buenos Aires, there is a lot
of great thing about it, It would be like saying I live in New York
City. Its a way of life and not meant for everyone. I was letting Deb
know there are choices. My husband and I have 6 children after
considering everything, Mendoza just fits the bill .
When
I reside in the US my job is that of helping the undocumented and
residents of hispanic decent, You made a comment that Argentines want
to flee to the United States. Do you have any idea waht is going on
here with all the immigration changes?? Since Jan 2008 ICE Law is in
effect. No undocumented person without a drivers license that is
stopped for a a traffic infraction is put in jail for 6-8 months until
deportation. Passengers that do not have ID are as well prosecuted in
the same manner. Most people have Tax payer ID numbers and pay taxes
but do not get refunds back. NO more drivers licenses are being issued
unless you have a social security number
Oh! by the way you
can't get married . Is this freedom??? People in Argentina are free to
make choices,( no many people work independentely there) they want to
flee because they think the grass is greener here and possibly they are
a bit lazy in thier own country!!!! I know I live in Argentina !!! I
have met over 5000 Argentinians in Texas in 2003. Went back this year
only 1500 left , they are all back home.
I hope to help you
in the future in some way, even after your negative words, for your
information money is not everything in life, we really believe that
Mendoza has a way of life to offer to raise a family.
Best Regards.
Viviana
NOTE: I have lived in USA 40 years
( san diego, las vegas, virginia, nashville and Destine, FL)"
There are a number of things Viviana wrote in her reply to Johny
that I don't understand, and I have a number of questions and
observations as follows:
1. "Johny, let me shed some light for you. I am trying to help expats
like you to make sound decisions for thier families."
How do you know what kind of expat Johny is or if he has a family?2.
"I am not
advertising my services."When you aren't scolding Johny or itemizing the problems facing the
undocumented in the US, your first post does appear to be plug for services to those who wish to emigrate to Argentina. Its just the reality of the words you
chose:"we help americans with travel, housing accomodations for vacations or your permanent move"If you do these services for free, please say so. Otherwise, I will continue to believe its an ad.
3. " My husband and I help expats get thier DNI's
and residency . "Is this a mission statement or an additional job description? In other words, are you altruists or do you charge for this service? Johny may not need residency or a DNI, anyway. He could be
here on a 90 day tourist visa or have the 90 day prorrogas de
permanencia and be completely legal...and, with the semi-annual trip to
Uruguay (or any other country), remain so in perpetuity. On the other
hand, he may already have is residency and DNI, as many of us do.
4. You continue with: "I do not know what your legal status is in Argentina
but I suppose you have been fortunate to take advantage of the benefits
of living abroad."?
The first half f the sentence is clear and objective, but is it fair to make any suppositions? By "living abroad" are you specifically referring to Argentina and what "benefits" do you suppose that Johny has been "taking advantage" of?
5. "When
I reside in the US my job is that of helping the undocumented and
residents of hispanic decent, You made a comment that Argentines want
to flee to the United States. Do you have any idea waht is going on
here with all the immigration changes?? Since Jan 2008 ICE Law is in
effect. No undocumented person without a drivers license that is
stopped for a a traffic infraction is put in jail for 6-8 months until
deportation. Passengers that do not have ID are as well prosecuted in
the same manner. Most people have Tax payer ID numbers and pay taxes
but do not get refunds back. NO more drivers licenses are being issued
unless you have a social security number"
OK, all factual info here: Undocumented individuals in any country face trouble with the
authorities. The consequences of being "caught" in Argentina with an
expired tourist visa aren't very drastic. Besides, relatively few foreigners
come here from the US or Europe without a return ticket or decide that
they want to stay in Argentina to live. Unlike the US, Argentina hasn't
been flooded with over ten million undocumented individuals who may or
may not be working (paying taxes at the lowest rates or not at all),
sending children to public schools, seeking health care for which they
cannot and usually do not pay, and possibly committing other criminal
acts which are far more common of "illegals" in the US than here.
6. You then make an exclimation and pose a question: "Oh! by the way you
can't get married . Is this freedom???
Even with my US citizenship, I could not marry an Argentine woman
and take her to the US to live without going through the lengthy legal pocess. Marriages of convenience for
the purpose of circumventing the US immigration laws are simply not accepted . It is true that I could "take advantage" of living in
Argentina and marry an Argentine woman for the benefit of obtaining
residency here, but I took the less complicated approach by obtaining
the visa rentista (ultimately, on my own with just the help of an interpreter for a couple hours). I was able to do so because I"have been fortunate to take advantage of the benefits
of living" in the US for the first 50 years of my life and have something to show for it. Now Argentina is getting it.
7-9. "People in Argentina are free to
make choices,( no many people work independentely there) they want to
flee because they think the grass is greener here and possibly they are
a bit lazy in thier own country!!!! I know I live in Argentina !!! I
have met over 5000 Argentinians in Texas in 2003. Went back this year
only 1500 left , they are all back home."This is a bit confusing do to the grammar. Are you saying that NOT
many Argentines work independently and they are indeed lazier in their
own country? Is this why 70 percent of them have come back home from
Texas? Are you helping Argentines get out of the US, too?
10. "I hope to help you
in the future in some way, even after your negative words, for your
information money is not everything in life, we really believe that
Mendoza has a way of life to offer to raise a family."
In spite of the rather condescending comment about money not being
"everything in life" (something Johny could already know), Mendoza may
indeed be a family friendly paradise compared to Buenos Aires. After seeing the photos
in the links, I want to go there, at least to visit. I swore (after
living in Park City, Utah for 15 years) I never again would live where
it snowed, but I've also learned to never say never.
The bottom line is: Being a real expat definitely beats the helloutof
being a wannabe expat, now, here, in Buenos Aires, at least for me,
even with all of the dangers...and the drama.