Hmmm- I know at least 5 people personally in the USA who have died from Covid, and a few others who have gotten it and survived. None of my friends in BA have gotten sick. The death toll in all of argentina (40 million people) is only a bit over double the death toll in my state of Washington (7 million people) - which means the per capita rates are much better in Argentina.
I would say argentina has come out far better than the US, which is seeing more deaths every week than the sum total in Argentina. And its getting worse up here- people are starting to ignore mask and social distance rules, and the case loads are going up, just as you would expect. I have no doubt the USA will hit a quarter million deaths by the end of the year.
My argentine friends grumble, but follow the rules, and case counts are, per capita, quite low- about 1/5 of Chile, for example.
1. We are in Canada, not the US.
(We actually have already gotten sick, my whole family, because we were in New York in mid-March. Then again, that was at a family event - in fact some of my Argentine family got infected there too, and developed symptoms upon their return to Buenos Aires.
If we hadn’t moved and thus caught it
with them in NY, we’d almost certainly have caught it
from them back in BsAs.)
2. I know several people who have COVID-19 right now in Argentina, or had in the past weeks. I know at least 2 people who died. And it isn’t getting better.
3. Given geographical and political realities, there’s not much point in referring simply to “the US”. New York’s case and death count are now highly manageable, in fact lower per capita than Argentina. With about twice the population of New York State, Argentina has nearly 10 times the new case count and over 20 times as many deaths. (This is incidentally yet another indicator of Argentina severely undercounting confirmed cases, even accounting for the lag between infection and death). And this is with a much more severe quarantine.
4. I would refer you to my comments on the other thread (
original and
follow-up) about the contrast between Canada and the US is handling of the pandemic, which also offers an interesting contrast with Argentinas policy.
In short, Argentina looks set to reap all of the havoc of an economic shutdown with none of the benefits that such a shut down would have offered when done properly.