I live in Boulder CO when Iḿ not down here. Its gotten very expensive, and for years I told people they should consider Boise because it has a lot of the charm (university, small city layout, surrounded by beautiful nature) and at the time it was maybe half the price. I think a lot of people realized it, and went there during the pandemic when remote work enabled people to escape the cities. So now its less of a bargain. They have a nice little tango scene, some hep spots, some ethnic restaurants, and because its a college town, more culture than normal in a city that size.The summer weather was glorious, but I imagine winter is long. I actually found it more charming than Boulder (this is maybe 6 years back), but lacking the urban escape hatch of Denver. Once you are there, the nearest city is Salt lake (4.5 hours driving) or Portland (6.5). The question of being a blue dot in a sea of red (politically speaking) means, for instance, abortion is illegal from the moment of fertilization. Oh and you have the Aryan Nation and the Patriot front with a strong presence in the state, though not in Boise. Its interesting but a bit remote feeling, culturally its a bit of an island. It would be an extreme change from BA. Was South Bend Indiana on the list? I had a good feeling from that place, and its close to Chicago.