I LOVE these economic discussions. Thanks to you all for posting your thoughts. I'm afraid they are not nearly as interesting as some of my discussions with Argentines though. Here is an example. I have a friend here who is a retired lawyer. She considers herself middle class, though with rising costs she is struggling on retirement. She has worked in government and tells me how completely corrupt it is.
Lately she has been attending some meetings/classes/whatever about how capitalism is causing all the world problems. Capitalism has to go!!!i
First off, she is confused about the definition of capitalism. If I see a need, and I invest my money in a business and run that business in the hope of a profit, I am a capitalist. However, if I am part of a large corporation and I maneuver my way into government position to control people and government, then we have fascism, i.e., government by corporations. The difference seems to slip the knowledge of most people.
But she now thinks all capitalism should be done away. What is the solution? Government should run everything. Where is the logical thinking?. Government here is completely corrupt in her thinking, but government should own and control everything and take care of everybody.
Another discussion with my spanish teacher--also degreed--about socialism in Argentina. She finally saw that no way could Argentina collect enough taxes to pay for all the stuff they offer in order to buy people's votes, and so they inflate, every so often when it just can't continue any longer, they devalue, people lose half of everything they saved and THEN the tax is paid, but they dont understand it is the hidden "inflation tax." They think it is just that the economy went awry with no idea why. The teacher finally got it. Was it an "Aha" moment for her that would change her approach to things? No, she was visibly upset. She said, "But it shouldn't BE that way, we should not have to think about economics, we should be able to give ourselves to CULTURE, to the arts, to opera, to education. We should not have to think about ecoomics!"
Go figure!
I do know Argentines who are more savvy though. Sadly they plan to leave the country if the current administration isn't removed in the next election. They are the kind of people we NEED in Argentina, in my opinion.