I'm sorry, but match.com is rubbish (and expensive)...and believe me, I've tried every dating site since the internet began! One person getting lucky on their first date does NOT make it any good - in fact, that person is the last person to expect to give an objective opinion!
I know that I was exceptionally lucky to say the least to have met my husband on the first try through Match, but as far as I am concerned, it wouldn't have mattered if it had taken me an additional 5, 10, 100+ dates with other people if I still wound up with him. It was still worth it in the end for me. Trust me, I had had my fair share of horrible dates from online and "real world" experiences, which is why I recognize a good person/opportunity when I see it, hence the reason I feel as strongly as I do.
I respect your opinion (everyone's got one!), but I wouldn't necessarily go raining on a happy person's parade (what's the point?).
Who's to say that I was the exception to the rule and you (a person who hasn't found anyone on the internet yet long-term) were not? I didn't sign up for Match as a fluke- My mom met her husband on the site, too, not to mention quite a few other cases that I personally know of.
To each his own! <3