citygirl said:I actually refused to do it on the 2 times employees tried to sue (in 3 years). All the employees were 100% in white, they had QUIT and then threatened to sue. I think they were shocked when I refused to settle with them, they were 100% expecting it. We went to the initial arbitration and they sat there expecting the offer. I told them they were welcome to move forward with the suit but i had signed employee contracts, proof of payments, certified F/S that matched the payments, email records, proof of electronic entry/exit from the premises, etc, etc, etc.
In both cases, they dropped the lawsuit at the end after realizing I wouldn't cave and just settle to make it go away. And that it would take years to get to court and while there was no guarantee (it's Argentina after all), there was a really good chance they would lose.
Sometimes not settling works here. (In both cases, I went against my lawyer's advice to settle). I refused to do it on principle and it wound up working out.
Yup I think we share views on this. On the advice of our lawyers we did settle some early lawsuits with people asking to be fired so they could be paid, rather than quit. The sums were small, the lawyers advised that this is how things work in Argentina. We then started to see a trend and a poor atmosphere permeate some groups in the company until 1 girl with us 5 years simply refused to do her job. She would turn up every day, do a few hours then say we were asking too much of her and leave and her response to mgmt and HR was "What are you going to do about it? Fire me!"...so we did, without paying and I, point blank and against the advice of our lawyers, refused to pay, as like you citygirl we have always worked en blanco, had all our ts crossed and is dotted re contracts, job descriptions, goals and objectives, performance reviews etc. I felt and still feel that justice has to be done if not for us as owners but for the dedicated professionals who turn up every day and give their all and who wouldnt dream of acting in this way. It is they who we disappoint when we roll over and pay fraudulent suits simply because thats the way things are done here. Her lawsuit is dropped, staff attitude 100% improved and we have changed to new lawyers who share our views...